Doug Fabian's 1st Quarter 2005 Lemon List Hits Record 1/2 Trillion in Assets - Top Lemon Award: Fidelity Magellan with $60 Billion

Share Article

For the first time in history, Fidelity Magellan, the flagship fund formerly managed by Peter Lynch, has appeared on the Lemon List. That means in the 1st Quarter 2005, Magellan under-performed its peer group average for large-cap core mutual funds by 25% for the past 12 months, and also under-performed its peer group for the past three- and five-year periods.

Since its inception in 1998, many surprises have appeared on Doug Fabian's Quarterly Lemon Lists, and this quarter is no exception. For the first time in history, Fidelity Magellan, the flagship fund formerly managed by Peter Lynch, has appeared on the Lemon List. That means in the 1st Quarter 2005, Magellan under-performed its peer group average for large-cap core mutual funds by 25% for the past 12 months, and also under-performed its peer group for the past three- and five-year periods. Since many 401(k) and pension funds use Magellan as a primary holding, Magellan's appearance is a significant event, and the fund's lack of performance is hurtful to millions of shareholders.

Using the above criteria, Fabian's Lemon List identifies under-performing funds, and frequently fund families such as Putnam, American Express and Janus are seen as big losers. Now, Fidelity Magellan, a fund with an outstanding reputation in the 1980s and early 1990s cannot sustain upward mobility or even keep pace with the S&P's five-year performance of -3.16%. With $60 billion in assets, portfolio manager Robert Stansky must stick with large cap stocks, and lemon stocks like AIG and Home Depot have depressed the fund's overall performance. Now Magellan simply can't even compete with the average performance of other managers.

"Investors and portfolio managers would be much better off selling their Magellan holdings and putting their money into funds with similar objectives like Selected American Shares (SLASX) or Oakmark Fund (OAKMX)," says Doug Fabian, president of Fabian Wealth Strategies and editor of Successful Investing, an investment advisory service with a 28-year track record. "Five years ago, if an investor had put $100,000 into Oakmark Fund instead of Magellan, they would have $170,259 today instead of a paltry $76,164 in the Magellan fund. That's the price of a house in some parts of the USA, or at least a hefty down payment."

To view the total Lemon List, see http://www.dougfabian.com. The top ten Lemons on Fabian's Lemon List, in order of asset size are below:

Fund Name            Ticker    Obj    Assets (Millions)    1 Yr    3 Yr    5 Yr    Exp Ratio

Fidelity Magellan Fund        FMAGX    LCC    59656.70        3.14    0.43    -5.30    0.70

Fidelity Blue Chip Growth    FBGRX    LCC    22686.50        1.04    -1.26    -7.67    0.68

AXP:New Dimensions;A, B, Y    INNDX    LCC    13500.80        -1.57    -1.42    -7.23    0.91

Oppenheimer Capital

Appreciation A, B, Y, C        OPTFX    LCC    8465.60            2.59    0.53    -5.75    1.09

AIM:Premium Equity A, B, C    AVLFX    LCC    6465.70            3.43    -2.36    -9.45    1.26

Janus Worldwide            JAWWX    GL    6400.70            -0.61    -0.92    -11.18    0.92

T Rowe Price International;

Shares, Adv            PRITX    INTL    5289.30            9.10    6.28    -4.79    0.95

Vanguard US Growth;Inv        VWUSX    LCG    5184.30            -0.76    -3.88    -15.75    0.53

Fidelity Aggressive Grow    FDEGX    MLG    4594.90            -2.43    -3.02    -23.05    0.83

AllianBer Large Cap Growth B,

A, Adv, C            APGBX    LCG    4501.90            -0.71    -4.37    -14.34    2.34

About Doug Fabian:

Doug Fabian began his 26-year investment career in 1979 as a fund analyst for the Telephone Switch Newsletter--the mutual fund review his father started in 1977. He is now president of Fabian Wealth Strategies, and editor of Successful Investing, a newsletter advisory service. He regularly appears at seminars around the country and hosts Southern California's number one investment talk radio show, "Making Money with Doug Fabian." Fabian has appeared on the pages of the large newspapers such The Wall Street Journal, Los Angeles Times, Orange County Register and The Sacramento Bee. He also appears regularly on national television such as CBNC and Fox News, and locally on KTLA in Los Angeles.

# # #

Share article on social media or email:

View article via:

Pdf Print

Contact Author

Darlene March
Visit website