(PRWEB) March 21, 2005
Disability Advocates Support and Thank Tom Harkin Â Schiavo Case is About Disability Rights
ItÂs time for the press to talk to the real experts on the Schiavo case, the disability rights movement. Not Dead Yet has led the disability communityÂs opposition to non-voluntary euthanasia for a decade. Diane Coleman, the groupÂs founder and president, and Stephen Drake, its research analyst, are available in Chicago to discuss the disability angle on the recent legislative and legal developments in the case.
The "right to life" movement has embraced Terri Schindler-Schiavo as a cause to prove "sanctity of life." The "right to die" movement argues that people in guardianship should have no protection against private family decisions to kill them. Yet the life-and-death issues surrounding Terri Schindler-Schiavo are first and foremost disability rights issues -- issues which affect tens of thousands of people with disabilities who, like Ms. Schindler-Schiavo, cannot currently articulate their views and so must rely on others as substitute decision-makers.
ThatÂs why 26 national disability rights organizations have adopted a position in support of Terri SchiavoÂs right to continue to receive food and water. The evidence that Ms. Schiavo would refuse tube feeding is so unclear and conflicted that it does not satisfy legal standards. The lower court in Florida can pretend otherwise, and the Florida appellate courts can refuse to question the lower court judge, but it serves society poorly to give guardians such an unfettered right to kill.
ÂWe applaud Senator Tom Harkin, the long time supporter of the civil rights of people with disabilities, for his insight into the disability issues that underlie this high profile case,Â said Coleman, Âand for his political courage in working beyond partisanship to uphold our fundamental rights.Â
ÂBioethicists like Art Caplan have tried to make this part of the right vs. left culture war,Â said Drake, Âbut thatÂs a shallow and dishonest portrayal of whatÂs going on in our health care system. While he talks about patient choice on TV, Caplan has been advocating futility guidelines that give doctors the authority to overrule family decisions back in Pennsylvania. The hypocrisy of these stances has gone unnoticed in the media, where he works to silence the voice of the disability rights community.Â
Not Dead Yet is a national disability rights group that has worked to organize the disability opposition to nonvoluntary euthanasia for over a decade.
Not Dead Yet
7521 Madison St.
Forest Park, IL 60130