Helium Report: Look Before Leaping Into Destination Club Membership

Share Article

Benefits are compelling and industry model is viable, but some clubs will struggle.

Helium Report today announced the release of the most comprehensive, objective guide to destination clubs, the fastest-growing sector in luxury vacation travel.

Destination clubs provide affluent families access to large luxury homes typical of private vacation residences, coupled with the high-end amenities and services of five-star hotels, and with the flexibility and choice of a world-wide network of homes in dozens of destinations. Membership costs typically include a one-time deposit of approximately $300,000 and an annual fee near $20,000. A large portion of the deposit is returned when a member leaves the club. These costs and terms can vary substantially. There are over twenty clubs, including industry leaders Exclusive Resorts and Tanner & Haley.

The new 50-page Helium Report: Decision Guide to Destination Clubs analyzes the cost/benefit tradeoffs of destination clubs against traditional options such as timeshares, home purchase, luxury hotels, and single-residence clubs such as the Four Seasons. “We find destination clubs to be a viable and attractive new offering,” says Helium Report CEO Greg Shove, “For the right customer, the cost is equivalent or better than 5 star hotels or luxury rentals, and the benefits are superior. The new Helium Report addresses these questions: are you the right customer, and which club is best for you.”

Club benefits typically include 30-days of vacation time at club residences, travel-planning services, online booking, on-site concierge, grocery-buying, cleaning, and other in-residence services. The residences are typically $2-4 million homes, with luxury kitchens, AV systems and other amenities. “There are exceptions on both ends,” says Bill Youstra, Helium Report’s Executive Editor, “While the average buy-in is $300,000, they range from under $100,000 to over $1 million. The home quality and amenities scale accordingly.”

The Decision Guide emerged from interviews with club founders, CEOs, members and prospective members. “One member summarized it this way: it’s all about the extra bedroom. This provides the flexibility for bringing another family, in-laws, or children’s friends,” said Shove, “Another remarked that in the one year as a member, he’s seen his relatives more than in the past ten years.”

Nonetheless, there are areas of concern. “You’re buying into a frothy new category,” notes Jamie Cheng, the lead author of the report, “Each club has a unique pricing plan, ownership structure and risk profile. We’ve already seen a small number of start-up clubs slow or stall.”

In general “non-equity” destination clubs commit to refund the majority of the membership deposit when a member wants out, typically when three new members join. “We’re looking for greater transparency and assurance,” comments Shove, “There have been improvements, but they’re inconsistent across the industry. “This is a six figure financial decision, so ‘Buyer beware’ holds true in destination clubs.” A more recent industry development is that some clubs offer members a deed or investment interest on the portfolio of homes, so that in the event of a club failure, the member would still hold an asset reflecting the initial deposit. “If a prospective member cannot get answers to the important due diligence questions, then we suggest they consider another club,” advises Shove.

The Helium Report: Decision Guide to Destination Clubs – available at http://www.heliumreport.com – offers an overview of the industry, comparison tables, cost-per-night analysis, summaries of each club, and a breakdown of membership options and risks. A section titled “Analyze” discusses key parameters and worst-case scenarios, compares equity versus non-equity models, and debunks the often misleading member-to-home ratio. The heliumreport.com website offers prospective members ongoing commentary and a list of 175 Key Questions to consider when evaluating club membership.

Note To The Editor

If you would like to receive a copy of the Helium Report: Decision Guide to Destination Clubs, or speak with a Helium Report analyst, please send an email with your full contact details to jamie@heliumreport.com


Helium Report surveyed active destination clubs. Each club was sent Helium Report’s destination club survey and interviews were conducted with club executives and/or founders. Additionally, Helium Report interviewed current members and prospective members at each stage in the decision process.

About Helium Report

Helium Report provides objective guidance and information to affluent consumers at http://www.heliumreport.com and in published reports and buyer’s guides. Helium Report is an independent new media venture that is not affiliated with any media company or destination club.

# # #

Share article on social media or email:

View article via:

Pdf Print

Contact Author

Jamie Cheng
Visit website