Finally, an Uptick in How Marketing Is Viewed. The Notre Dame – Socratic Technologies Index of Consumer Sentiment toward Marketing (ICSM)

Share Article

After years of negative reactions to the way marketing is perceived, overall consumer sentiment toward marketing turned positive for the first time in 2011. (MacElroy, Etzel, Gaski 2011)

After years of negative reactions to the way marketing is perceived, overall consumer sentiment toward marketing turned positive for the first time in 2011. The Notre Dame – Socratic Technologies Index of Consumer Sentiment toward Marketing (ICSM) edged into the positive range at 5.5 on a scale of -200 to +200, after more than 25 years of consistently negative ratings.

A long-term study conducted by two University of Notre Dame marketing professors in conjunction with the marketing research firm, Socratic Technologies of San Francisco, examines U.S. consumers’ perceptions of product quality, fairness of prices, usefulness of advertising, and retail service. The research has tracked consumer sentiment toward marketing since 1984, using a 20-item validated questionnaire and data collected by Socratic from a nationwide sample.

As early as the mid-1960s, a customer-oriented approach to marketing has been touted as the path to success by most business consultants, authors and business educators. In short, managers were advised that satisfying customers and focusing on their needs would produce positive results for an organization. However, prior to this project there’s been no effort to systematically examine how consumers feel marketers are treating them.

One might expect that if managers are behaving in a customer-oriented fashion, consumers’ perceptions of product value, the fairness of prices, the usefulness of advertising, and the quality of service should individually or collectively receive a positive rating. However, that has not been the case until now.

Bill MacElroy, chairman of Socratic, notes a possible link with sentiments toward corporate brands. “In periods where there have been economic upheavals and corresponding drops in the ICSM, we've seen a correlation with lower overall brand scores. For example, in 2009, a fairly significant drop in the consumer sentiment scores corresponds to similar drops in "trust" and "credibility" scores we measured for many corporate brands in the same period. We see a similar relationship in the data in the early 1990s, when another economic downturn occurred. Conversely, we saw an across the board improvement in brand scores in 2010 and early 2011, which also tracks nicely with the ICSM data.”

Should marketers be satisfied with the performance reflected in the Index or should there be concern that the institution is not viewed more positively? It is almost certain that negative (or barely positive) perceptions make the task of marketing more difficult. However, it’s unlikely that individual marketers can have a significant impact on overall sentiment. Therefore, the recommendation that an individual organization should emphasize a customer orientation appears valid as it will position it favorably relative to the general perception.

The entire historical pattern of ICSM as well as additional information can be obtained from the researchers, Professor Michael Etzel (metzel@nd.edu) or Professor John Gaski (jgaski(at)nd(dot)edu).

Complete details and validation results for the scale are presented in the Journal of Marketing, July, 1986, pp. 71-81.

A detailed report of earlier results appears in the Journal of Consumer Research, March 2005, pp. 859-867.

About Socratic Technologies, Inc.

Socratic Technologies, Inc. has been a leader in the science of computer-based and interactive research methods since 1994. Headquartered in San Francisco, it is a research-based consultancy that builds proprietary, interactive tools that accelerate and improve research methods for the study of global markets. Socratic Technologies specializes in brand articulation and product development research for the high technology and consumer technology sectors.

###

Share article on social media or email:

View article via:

Pdf Print

Contact Author

Bill MacElroy
Socratic Technologies, Inc.
415 430 2200
Email >
Visit website