No More for the Road: Pennsylvania Personal Injury Attorneys See Growing Liability for Bars that Serve Intoxicated Patrons

Share Article

Two separate wrongful death lawsuits filed in the Court of Common Pleas in Philadelphia County this August highlight the rippling effects of drunken driving accidents and the need for drinking establishments to serve with greater responsibility. The parents of Zachary Hartwell, a passenger in former Jackass star Ryan Dunn’s Porsche 911, filed a wrongful death suit against Dunn’s estate and Barnaby’s West Chester – the bar that allegedly continued to serve Dunn alcohol even after he appeared intoxicated. Hartwell and Dunn died after Dunn allegedly lost control of his vehicle and violently crashed in West Goshen, PA in 2011.The second lawsuit, filed by the widow of fallen Philadelphia Highway Patrol Officer Brian Lorenzo, names both the alleged driver who struck her husband as well as the Bensalem T.G.I. Friday’s that allegedly served him alcohol in the hours prior to the collision. Lorenzo died in a head-on collision after John D Leck, Jr. reportedly drove the wrong way down I-95 in Philadelphia, according to the Philadelphia Inquirer. Distributed by Console & Hollawell P.C.

News Image
“Alcohol-related deaths are an absolute epidemic in our country...The only way victims will have justice is if we can hold those responsible accountable for their reckless actions. Every day we wait more lives are lost.

Two separate wrongful death lawsuits filed in the Court of Common Pleas in Philadelphia County this August highlight the rippling effects of drunken driving accidents and the need for drinking establishments to serve with greater responsibility. The parents of Zachary Hartwell, a passenger in Jackass star Ryan Dunn’s Porsche 911, filed a wrongful death suit against Dunn’s estate and Barnaby’s West Chester – the bar that allegedly continued to serve Dunn alcohol even after he appeared intoxicated. Hartwell and Dunn died after Dunn allegedly lost control of his vehicle and violently crashed in West Goshen, PA in 2011.The second lawsuit, filed by the widow of fallen Philadelphia Highway Patrol Officer Brian Lorenzo, names both the alleged driver who struck her husband as well as the Bensalem T.G.I. Friday’s that allegedly served him alcohol in the hours prior to the collision. Lorenzo died in a head-on collision after John D Leck, Jr. reportedly drove the wrong way down I-95 in Philadelphia, according to the Philadelphia Inquirer.

“Serving alcohol to guests who appear drunk is illegal in Pennsylvania,” says Bensalem car accident attorney Richard P. Console, Jr. “Restaurants and bars have legal obligations to stop pouring drinks and cut guests off when they start to show signs of intoxication. If the allegations in these filed court documents are true, the businesses named in these lawsuits could face significant liability.”

Known nationally as the Dram Shop Act, this rule makes businesses that sell or serve alcoholic drinks to visibility intoxicated patrons liable for any injuries the intoxicated guests cause as a result. Currently, 38 states across the country, including Pennsylvania, have Dram Shop laws on the books. According to the complaints, Hartwell’s parents are seeking both compensatory and punitive damages from Dunn’s estate and Barnaby’s West Chester. Officer Lorenzo’s widow is seeking lost monetary support and expenses related to the loss of her husband and father to her three children.

The loss of Officer Lorenzo, a 23-year veteran, was felt keenly across multiple police departments throughout the Philadelphia metro area.

“The unit he (Lorenzo) was in is a very close-knit unit,” says Philadelphia Police Lieutenant Ray Evers, “especially the officers within Highway Patrol who’re on motorcycles it’s very close. We had motorcycle officers from many departments come to his services not only to honor him, but also because Officer Lorenzo trained probably any police department within a 75-mile radius of Philadelphia he trained a lot, if not all, of the motorcycle cops in the tri-state area. He was well known for being one of the best riders in the area. That’s the type of guy he was.”

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimate that nearly 30 people die every day in the United States in motor vehicle accidents that involve at least one driver impaired by alcohol. That statistic amounts to one death every 48 minutes nationwide and generates an annual cost exceeding $51 billion. Richard P. Console, Jr., and other personal injury attorneys in Philadelphia are appalled by the numbers.

“Alcohol-related deaths are an absolute epidemic in our country,” says Console. “The only way victims will have justice is if we can hold those responsible accountable for their reckless actions. Every day we wait more lives are lost.”

Console & Hollawell P.C. is a personal injury law firm helping victims injured by drunken driving accidents across New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Since 1994, award-winning attorneys at the firm have obtained personal injury settlements for 5,000 clients.

Docket #s: Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas.
Hartwell -- 120800300
Lorenzo -- 120704658

Share article on social media or email:

View article via:

Pdf Print

Contact Author

Richard Console
Visit website