Herniated and Bulging Spinal Discs: Are They the Same Thing?

Share Article

Dr. Kaixuan Liu with Atlantic Spine Center with tips on the differences and similarities between the 2 common back conditions

Dr. Kaixuan Liu

The bottom line is that bulging discs and herniated discs (also called ruptured discs) are two different problems.

There’s a lot of confusing lingo out there surrounding spinal disc problems, with many people wondering if herniated and bulging discs are the same thing. But it’s crucial to understand both the differences and similarities between these two highly common back conditions in order to seek proper treatment, according to Kaixuan Liu, MD, PhD, founder and president of Atlantic Spine Center.

The bottom line is that bulging discs and herniated discs (also called ruptured discs) are two different problems. But they can cause similar symptoms, though treatment for each can vary widely depending on its severity, Dr. Liu says. Understanding the anatomy of the spine is key to differentiating the two.

“The spine’s vertebrae are separated by spongy, oval-shaped discs that serve to cushion the spinal column and maintain spaces between the bones,” explains Dr. Liu, who is fellowship-trained in minimally invasive spine surgery. “A bulging disc means that disc annulus is squeezed out of vertebral body surface, though the disc’s outer layer is intact and no center gel like sponge leak out the disc. Conversely, a herniated disc’s outer layer has broken, allowing the spongy center to leak out of disc and commonly into the spinal canal.”

Diagnosis relies on symptoms, imaging tests
Given these basic differences between the two conditions, you’d think each triggered a different set of symptoms. But that’s a misconception, Dr. Liu says. In reality, both bulging and herniated discs can irritate or press on nerve roots spreading from the spine to other body areas – causing pain and other potentially debilitating symptoms such as tingling, numbness and muscle weakness. Although bulging disc is often noted as normal disc, it is frequently associated with disc degeneration (aging) and produce similar symptoms as herniated disc.

About one-third of bulging or herniated discs don’t cause any symptoms, but herniated discs are more likely – because of their more severe nature – to trigger pain than bulging discs, he says. Herniated or bulging discs in the neck will produce symptoms in the neck, shoulder and arms, while herniated or bulging discs in the back will lead to symptoms in the lower back, buttocks, legs or feet.

Discerning whether a patient’s symptoms are caused by a bulging vs. a herniated disc depends on two factors: a thorough physical exam and imaging tests, such as x-ray or MRI scans, that can pinpoint exactly how damaged a spinal disc has become.

Treatment options for bulging or herniated discs
Fortunately, treatment options for either problem are extensive, Dr. Liu notes. But treatment approach depends on several factors, including severity and lengthy of symptoms; the patient’s age; and if extreme symptoms are present, such as intense numbness or weakness.

Conservative, non-surgical measures are appropriate and effective for most patients, he says. They include:

  •     Rest
  •     Prescription and over-the-counter medications, including NSAIDs (nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs), muscle relaxants or narcotics
  •     Physical therapy
  •     Steroids injected into the spinal area or taken orally, which control pain and reduce swelling
  •     Heat or ice
  •     Ultrasound
  •     Electrical stimulation

If surgery is necessary – which typically only occurs for herniated, not bulging, discs – that decision is made between doctor and patient only after conservative treatments haven’t produced any relief after 6 to 12 weeks.

“Surgery can include both minimally invasive or ‘open’ approaches, but it’s only considered as a last resort or if extreme and dangerous neurological symptoms are present,” Dr. Liu says. “The good news is we can provide substantial relief to the vast majority of patients with conservative measures, and they can quickly return to their favorite activities feeling much better.”

Atlantic Spine Center is a nationally recognized leader for endoscopic spine surgery with several locations in NJ and NYC. http://www.atlanticspinecenter.com, http://www.atlanticspinecenter.nyc

Kaixuan Liu, MD, Phd, is a board-certified physician who is fellowship-trained in minimally invasive spine surgery at Atlantic Spine Center.

Share article on social media or email:

View article via:

Pdf Print

Contact Author

Melissa Chefec
MCPR, LLC
+1 (203) 968-6625
Email >
Visit website