Harbinger Urges Shareholders to Take Action at Cleveland-Cliffs Special Meeting

Share Article

Harbinger Capital Partners® Funds, the largest shareholder of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc (NYSE: CLF), today sent the following letter to shareholders of Cleveland-Cliffs:

preserve the power of your vote



September 19, 2008

Dear Fellow Shareholder:

The October 3rd Cleveland-Cliffs special meeting is rapidly approaching. Once again, we are asking for your support now to authorize our acquisition under the Ohio control share acquisition statute of up to one-third of the voting shares of Cleveland-Cliffs. Please join us as we fight for the future of our shared investment and the interests of all shareholders.

The merger with Alpha Natural Resources is too much, too fast, and shows the urgent need for a strong, independent shareholder advocate that management cannot ignore.

We believe Cleveland-Cliffs is a company with tremendous potential. We do not want to see that potential squandered on a radical, transformative transaction that we believe destroys shareholder value and places the future of your company at substantial risk. According to the company's preliminary proxy statement/prospectus filed August 12, 2008, J.P. Morgan, the company's financial advisor, estimated the value creation per share to Cleveland-Cliffs shareholders in the Alpha transaction at only $1.85, assuming constant discount rates, or less than 1.66% of the company's share price at the time of announcement. The same filing discloses that Citigroup, Alpha's financial advisor, calculated that the transaction would be dilutive to Cleveland-Cliffs earnings per share by between negative 14-19% and negative 13-26% for 2009 and 2010, respectively.

When risk and reward are so out of proportion, shareholders need someone prepared to say "no" when "no" is the right answer.

Cleveland-Cliffs says it does not want Harbinger to exert control over the company and infringe on the rights of shareholders, yet the company has offered no evidence that Harbinger has ever sought to exert any such control. Indeed, the company acknowledged in its own proxy materials that Harbinger has not presented any demands or proposals to the company. The reality is that, given the range of statutory restrictions that limit our ability to enter into transactions with the company, we believe our greatest opportunity to achieve the most profitable return on our investment is to prompt and prod management toward transactions that benefit all shareholders.

Cleveland-Cliffs asks you to "preserve the power of your vote" and we cannot agree more. At a time when many companies are eliminating or placing time limits on poison pills and similar entrenchment tools, Cleveland-Cliffs remains subject to multiple layers of legal restrictions that insulate management against shareholders taking action. These range from the Ohio control share acquisition statute that requires Harbinger to obtain shareholder approval to increase our stake, to the two-third voting requirements that management has cited, to the Ohio business combination statute that drastically limits Harbinger's ability to acquire the company or assist others in acquiring the company. In this time of tremendous market volatility, we believe Cleveland-Cliffs management should be supportive of investors that want to purchase additional shares, rather than preserving outdated legal restrictions to block shareholder action.

If management believes that supermajority voting places too much power in the hands of large shareholders, they can take action to remove that requirement. Insulating management from shareholder action is not the answer.

Our interests are aligned with yours. We do not want to control Cleveland-Cliffs, but we do want to ensure that this company acts in the best interests of all shareholders. We understand that two of the proxy advisory firms have determined not to support our proposal. We urge all shareholders to make up their own minds, join with us, and help us fight for the cause of shareholder value.

We strongly encourage Cleveland-Cliffs shareholders to sign, date, and return the enclosed GREEN proxy card and the accompanying certificate of eligibility. If you have previously signed a white proxy card, you can revoke that vote by immediately signing, dating and mailing the enclosed GREEN proxy card and accompanying certificate of eligibility. Be sure to complete the certificate of eligibility to ensure that your vote is fully counted!

Shareholders who have questions about Harbinger's solicitation, or need assistance in voting their GREEN proxy card and completing the accompanying certificate of eligibility, should call Harbinger's proxy solicitors, Okapi Partners LLC, Toll-Free at (877) 869-0171, banks and brokers call collect at (212) 297-0720 or email at info@okapipartners.com.

Thank you for your careful consideration,





If you have questions about how to vote your shares, or need additional assistance, please contact the firm assisting us in the solicitation of proxies:   OKAPI PARTNERS LLC

CALL TOLL FREE: (877) 869-0171



EMAIL: info@okapipartners.com


We urge you NOT to sign any proxy card sent to you by Cleveland-Cliffs. If you have already done so, you have every legal right to change your vote TODAY by signing, dating and returning the enclosed GREEN proxy card and completing the accompanying certificate of eligibility (located on the reverse side of the proxy card) in the postage-paid envelope provided.

About Harbinger

The Harbinger Capital Partners® Funds investment team located in New York City manages in excess of $21 billion as of August 1, 2008. Our objective is to achieve superior absolute returns primarily through investments in distressed/high yield debt securities, special situation equities and private loans and notes. Harbinger Capital Partners Master Fund I, Ltd. focuses on event-driven situations, turnarounds and capital structure arbitrage, including both long and short positions in highly leveraged and financially distressed companies. Harbinger Capital Partners Special Situations Fund, L.P. is focused on medium to long term, control-oriented and frequently less liquid distressed investments, with flexibility to use other investment strategies and types of securities when attractive opportunities arise.

Cautionary Statement Regarding Forward-Looking Statements

This document contains forward-looking statements. These statements may be identified by the use of forward-looking terminology such as the words "expects," "intends," "believes," "anticipates" and other terms with similar meaning indicating possible future events or actions or potential impact on the business or shareholders of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc (the "Company"). These forward-looking statements are based on current expectations and assumptions that are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially, including the risk that Harbinger may not be able to complete the purchases of shares contemplated by the Harbinger share acquisition proposal, that market conditions, market prices, developments with the Company or changes in the Company's prospects may render such purchases financially undesirable to Harbinger or that Harbinger may not be able to acquire shares prior to any record date set for any special meeting called in connection with the Alpha Natural Resources, Inc. transaction or otherwise be able to obtain the ability to vote such shares at any such meeting. Accordingly, you should not rely upon forward-looking statements as a prediction of actual results.

Share article on social media or email:

View article via:

Pdf Print

Contact Author

Bruce H. Goldfarb
Harbinger Capital Partners
Email >