Physician-Patient Alliance for Health & Safety Says Recent Death of 17-Year Old From Unmonitored Tonsillectomy Should Never Have Happened

Share Article

Physician-Patient Alliance for Health & Safety says that the recent tragic death of 17-year old Mariah Edwards after having her tonsils removed underscores the urgent need to continuously electronically monitor all patients receiving opioids with oximetry and capnography, as well as ensure that alarm fatigue is managed appropriately.

17-year old Mariah Edwards dies after having her tonsils removed

A young girl died from a common procedure that hundreds of patients undergo every year because her caregivers choose to ignore the very monitors that were there to protect her life.

Past News Releases


In Willow Grove, PA, 17-year old Mariah Edwards went into a surgical center to remove her tonsils and died.

ABC News recently reported that the outpatient tonsillectomy was a success. Following the procedure she was moved to a recovery room. In the lawsuit filed on behalf of the Edwards family, it provides that nurses administered a dose of the painkiller fentanyl, a potent, synthetic narcotic analgesic with a rapid onset and short duration of action.

The Edwards’ attorney, Joel Feller, says that the narcotic threw Mariah into opioid-induced respiratory depression. However, the nurse who was supposed to be watching the teenager was busy tending to another patient.

Moreover, in discovery, a nurse for the surgical center admitted that the monitors attached to Mariah had been muted for sound.

“Tragedies like this should never happen,” says Michael Wong, founder and executive director of the Physician-Patient Alliance for Health & Safety (PPAHS), an advocacy group that is pushing for higher standards of care for patients receiving opioids. “A young girl died from a common procedure that hundreds of patients undergo every year because her caregivers choose to ignore the very monitors that were there to protect her life.”

According to ECRI Institute, an independent, nonprofit organization that researches the best approaches to improving the safety, quality, and cost-effectiveness of patient care, alarm hazards are again the number one health technology hazard for 2013. In its report, “2013 Top 10 Health Technology Hazards”, ECRI stated:

"Many medical devices in the hospital, such as physiologic monitors (including telemetry monitors), ventilators, infusion pumps, and dialysis units, rely on alarms to help protect patients. But the alarm systems on these devices can also be the source of problems, and there are times when alarms actually contribute to the occurrence of adverse events."

Dr. Robert Stoelting (President, Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation) explains the impact of false alarms on patient care, “APSF recommends that continuous electronic monitoring of oxygenation and ventilation be available and considered for all patients. This would reduce the likelihood of unrecognized clinically significant opioid-induced depression of ventilation in the postoperative period. However, continuous electronic monitoring may result in threshold-based alarms sounding frequently and the unfortunate consequence that the caregiver fails to recognize early signs of progressive hypoventilation by either being too sensitive (excess false alarms) or insufficiently sensitive.”

Reducing alarm fatigue and making alarms more actionable is a critical patient safety issue. Mr. Wong encourages the adoption of best practices, “There are hospitals that have been able to successfully address alarm fatigue, which might prevent what tragically happened to 17-year old Mariah Edwards. A recent study at The Johns Hopkins Hospital, for example, was able to reduce the number of alarms that sounded by 43 percent.”


The Physician-Patient Alliance for Health & Safety (PPAHS) is an advocacy group devoted to improving patient health and safety. PPAHS supporters include physicians, patients, individuals, and organizations.

PPAHS recently released a concise checklist that reminds caregivers of the essential steps needed to be taken to initiate Patient-Controlled Analgesia (PCA) with a patient and to continue to assess that patient’s use of PCA. For more information and to download the PCA safety checklist, please visit

Share article on social media or email:

View article via:

Pdf Print