Magna Legal Services Provides Courtroom Graphics & Jury Consultation in Trinity Industries Guardrail Fraud Case

Share Article

Texas Jury Awards $525 Million to Plaintiff in High-Profile Case

Magna Legal Services, one of the country’s largest jury research, litigation graphics and court reporting companies, recently played a pivotal role in the $525 million award – after mandatory trebling of a $175 million jury verdict -- for its law firm client, Boies, Schiller & Flexner, which represented the plaintiff Josh Harman. In the case (Harman on behalf of the U.S. v. Trinity Industries Inc., 12-cv-00089, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Texas (Marshall) Trinity Industries, the highway guardrail maker, was accused of selling systems that can malfunction during crashes and slice through cars. According to court documents, mandatory statutory penalties of as much as $185 million, prejudgment interest and attorneys’ fees are all expected to be added to the $525 million award before the court enters a judgment of approximately $1 billion against Trinity.

The case was brought under the False Claims Act by Harman, who discovered that the company made changes in 2005 to its railhead without telling the Federal Highway Administration. Court records state the company sold its guardrails to state governments that in turn received federal reimbursement. Trinity was found by a jury earlier in October to have defrauded the federal government. Magna Legal Services provided its patent-pending revolutionary online jury research focus group product, JuryConfirm, along with graphics consulting and design for the trial, and handled the trial presentation for Boies, Schiller & Flexner.

“As in many of our most significant cases, Magna was there for us every step of the way,” said Nicholas Gravante, Jr. of Boies, Schiller & Flexner, the lead partner on the case. “The personal service and dedication that Bob Ackerman, Rosalie Margolis and their incredible team did by providing graphics design, jury research and trial presentation was instrumental to our success in presenting this case to the jury, which took less than three hours to deliver the record-setting verdict achieved by our team.”

The use of mock trials and compelling visual graphics at trial is increasingly important, especially when conveying complex information for jurors. "Scientific research supports the concept that pairing the spoken word with strong visuals allows the presenter to make an effective and lasting argument" according to Magna Litigation Consultant Ron Kurzman. Evidence is the key to any trial, and making that evidence clear and concise is the key to having jurors learn and retain the information being presented. The employment of focus groups before the trial provides insight into the minds of prospective jurors and what is needed to better enable the actual panel to understand your case.

“The combination of what is learned from jury focus groups and implementation of that knowledge by our strong graphic design team continues to provide value to litigators with clear, concise information about the best demonstratives to make trial presentations more direct and vivid to juries,” noted Mark Calzaretta, Magna Legal Services partner.

About Magna:
Magna Legal Services is one of the largest jury research, litigation graphics and court reporting companies in the country, providing end-to-end legal support services to law firms, corporations and governmental agencies from its 18 offices in 13 states throughout the nation. As an end-to-end service provider, Magna provides strategic advantages to clients by offering legal support services at every stage of legal proceedings. Magna’s mission is to ensure that all legal support needs are delivered in a high quality, reliable and responsive manner.

Share article on socal media or email:

View article via:

Pdf Print

Contact Author

Peter Hecht