Accessibility Statement Skip Navigation
  • Why PRWeb
  • How It Works
  • Who Uses It
  • Pricing
  • Login
  • GDPR
  • Create a Free Account
Return to PRWeb homepage
  • News
  • Resources
  • Contact
When typing in this field, a list of search results will appear and be automatically updated as you type.

Searching for your content...

No results found. Please change your search terms and try again.
  • News in Focus
      • Browse News Releases

      • All News Releases
      • Multimedia Gallery

      • All Multimedia
      • All Photos
      • All Videos
  • Business & Money
      • Auto & Transportation

      • Aerospace, Defense
      • Air Freight
      • Airlines & Aviation
      • Automotive
      • Maritime & Shipbuilding
      • Railroads and Intermodal Transportation
      • Supply Chain/Logistics
      • Transportation, Trucking & Railroad
      • Travel
      • Trucking and Road Transportation
      • View All Auto & Transportation

      • Business Technology

      • Blockchain
      • Broadcast Tech
      • Computer & Electronics
      • Computer Hardware
      • Computer Software
      • Data Analytics
      • Electronic Commerce
      • Electronic Components
      • Electronic Design Automation
      • Financial Technology
      • High Tech Security
      • Internet Technology
      • Nanotechnology
      • Networks
      • Peripherals
      • Semiconductors
      • View All Business Technology

      • Entertain­ment & Media

      • Advertising
      • Art
      • Books
      • Entertainment
      • Film and Motion Picture
      • Magazines
      • Music
      • Publishing & Information Services
      • Radio & Podcast
      • Television
      • View All Entertain­ment & Media

      • Financial Services & Investing

      • Accounting News & Issues
      • Acquisitions, Mergers and Takeovers
      • Banking & Financial Services
      • Bankruptcy
      • Bond & Stock Ratings
      • Conference Call Announcements
      • Contracts
      • Cryptocurrency
      • Dividends
      • Earnings
      • Earnings Forecasts & Projections
      • Financing Agreements
      • Insurance
      • Investments Opinions
      • Joint Ventures
      • Mutual Funds
      • Private Placement
      • Real Estate
      • Restructuring & Recapitalization
      • Sales Reports
      • Shareholder Activism
      • Shareholder Meetings
      • Stock Offering
      • Stock Split
      • Venture Capital
      • View All Financial Services & Investing

      • General Business

      • Awards
      • Commercial Real Estate
      • Corporate Expansion
      • Earnings
      • Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG)
      • Human Resource & Workforce Management
      • Licensing
      • New Products & Services
      • Obituaries
      • Outsourcing Businesses
      • Overseas Real Estate (non-US)
      • Personnel Announcements
      • Real Estate Transactions
      • Residential Real Estate
      • Small Business Services
      • Socially Responsible Investing
      • Surveys, Polls and Research
      • Trade Show News
      • View All General Business

  • Science & Tech
      • Consumer Technology

      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Blockchain
      • Cloud Computing/Internet of Things
      • Computer Electronics
      • Computer Hardware
      • Computer Software
      • Consumer Electronics
      • Cryptocurrency
      • Data Analytics
      • Electronic Commerce
      • Electronic Gaming
      • Financial Technology
      • Mobile Entertainment
      • Multimedia & Internet
      • Peripherals
      • Social Media
      • STEM (Science, Tech, Engineering, Math)
      • Supply Chain/Logistics
      • Wireless Communications
      • View All Consumer Technology

      • Energy & Natural Resources

      • Alternative Energies
      • Chemical
      • Electrical Utilities
      • Gas
      • General Manufacturing
      • Mining
      • Mining & Metals
      • Oil & Energy
      • Oil and Gas Discoveries
      • Utilities
      • Water Utilities
      • View All Energy & Natural Resources

      • Environ­ment

      • Conservation & Recycling
      • Environmental Issues
      • Environmental Policy
      • Environmental Products & Services
      • Green Technology
      • Natural Disasters
      • View All Environ­ment

      • Heavy Industry & Manufacturing

      • Aerospace & Defense
      • Agriculture
      • Chemical
      • Construction & Building
      • General Manufacturing
      • HVAC (Heating, Ventilation and Air-Conditioning)
      • Machinery
      • Machine Tools, Metalworking and Metallurgy
      • Mining
      • Mining & Metals
      • Paper, Forest Products & Containers
      • Precious Metals
      • Textiles
      • Tobacco
      • View All Heavy Industry & Manufacturing

      • Telecomm­unications

      • Carriers and Services
      • Mobile Entertainment
      • Networks
      • Peripherals
      • Telecommunications Equipment
      • Telecommunications Industry
      • VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol)
      • Wireless Communications
      • View All Telecomm­unications

  • Lifestyle & Health
      • Consumer Products & Retail

      • Animals & Pets
      • Beers, Wines and Spirits
      • Beverages
      • Bridal Services
      • Cannabis
      • Cosmetics and Personal Care
      • Fashion
      • Food & Beverages
      • Furniture and Furnishings
      • Home Improvement
      • Household, Consumer & Cosmetics
      • Household Products
      • Jewelry
      • Non-Alcoholic Beverages
      • Office Products
      • Organic Food
      • Product Recalls
      • Restaurants
      • Retail
      • Supermarkets
      • Toys
      • View All Consumer Products & Retail

      • Entertain­ment & Media

      • Advertising
      • Art
      • Books
      • Entertainment
      • Film and Motion Picture
      • Magazines
      • Music
      • Publishing & Information Services
      • Radio & Podcast
      • Television
      • View All Entertain­ment & Media

      • Health

      • Biometrics
      • Biotechnology
      • Clinical Trials & Medical Discoveries
      • Dentistry
      • FDA Approval
      • Fitness/Wellness
      • Health Care & Hospitals
      • Health Insurance
      • Infection Control
      • International Medical Approval
      • Medical Equipment
      • Medical Pharmaceuticals
      • Mental Health
      • Pharmaceuticals
      • Supplementary Medicine
      • View All Health

      • Sports

      • General Sports
      • Outdoors, Camping & Hiking
      • Sporting Events
      • Sports Equipment & Accessories
      • View All Sports

      • Travel

      • Amusement Parks and Tourist Attractions
      • Gambling & Casinos
      • Hotels and Resorts
      • Leisure & Tourism
      • Outdoors, Camping & Hiking
      • Passenger Aviation
      • Travel Industry
      • View All Travel

  • Policy & Public Interest
      • Policy & Public Interest

      • Advocacy Group Opinion
      • Animal Welfare
      • Congressional & Presidential Campaigns
      • Corporate Social Responsibility
      • Domestic Policy
      • Economic News, Trends, Analysis
      • Education
      • Environmental
      • European Government
      • FDA Approval
      • Federal and State Legislation
      • Federal Executive Branch & Agency
      • Foreign Policy & International Affairs
      • Homeland Security
      • Labor & Union
      • Legal Issues
      • Natural Disasters
      • Not For Profit
      • Patent Law
      • Public Safety
      • Trade Policy
      • U.S. State Policy
      • View All Policy & Public Interest

  • People & Culture
      • People & Culture

      • Aboriginal, First Nations & Native American
      • African American
      • Asian American
      • Children
      • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
      • Hispanic
      • Lesbian, Gay & Bisexual
      • Men's Interest
      • People with Disabilities
      • Religion
      • Senior Citizens
      • Veterans
      • Women
      • View All People & Culture

  • Hamburger menu
  • Cision PRWeb provides efficient communication tools to continuously engage with target audiences across multiple online channels
  • Create a Free Account
    • ALL CONTACT INFO
    • Contact Us


      11AM ET Sunday – 8PM ET Friday

  • Send a Release
  • Sign up
  • Log in
  • Resources
  • RSS
  • GDPR
  • News in Focus
    • Browse All News
    • Multimedia Gallery
  • Business & Money
    • Auto & Transportation
    • Business Technology
    • Entertain­ment & Media
    • Financial Services & Investing
    • General Business
  • Science & Tech
    • Consumer Technology
    • Energy & Natural Resources
    • Environ­ment
    • Heavy Industry & Manufacturing
    • Telecomm­unications
  • Lifestyle & Health
    • Consumer Products & Retail
    • Entertain­ment & Media
    • Health
    • Sports
    • Travel
  • Policy & Public Interest
  • People & Culture
    • People & Culture
  • Send a Release
  • Sign up
  • Log in
  • Resources
  • RSS
  • GDPR
  • Send a Release
  • Sign up
  • Log in
  • Resources
  • RSS
  • GDPR
  • Send a Release
  • Sign up
  • Log in
  • Resources
  • RSS
  • GDPR

SCOTUS Determines ERISA’s “Church Plan” Exemption Applies Broadly to Church Affiliates, Leaving Thousands of Employees Without ERISA’s Protections
  • USA - English


News provided by

Springer Ayeni, A Professional Law Corp

Jun 06, 2017, 17:10 ET

Share this article

Share toX

Share this article

Share toX

Springer Ayeni, A Professional Law Corporation, with offices in Oakland and San Jose, CA
Springer Ayeni, A Professional Law Corporation, with offices in Oakland and San Jose, CA

(PRWEB) June 06, 2017 -- By Claire Kennedy-Wilkins, of Counsel at Springer Ayeni, A Professional Law Corporation; http://www.benefitslaw.com

Most notably impacted are hundreds of thousands of employees of hospitals affiliated with religious organizations, whose benefits will no longer be protected by ERISA’s funding requirements, fiduciary duty rules, and anti-pension cut-back provision

Post this

The Supreme Court held on Monday that employee benefit plans maintained by the internal benefit committees of church-affiliated non-profits, such as hospitals, do not need to be established by a church in order to fall within the Employee Retirement Income Security Act’s (“ERISA”) “church plan” exemption. Advocate Health Care Network v. Stapleton, No. 16-258 ___ S.Ct. ___, 2017 WL 2407476 (2017). Most notably impacted are hundreds of thousands of employees of hospitals affiliated with religious organizations, whose benefits will no longer be protected by ERISA’s funding requirements, fiduciary duty rules, and anti-pension cut-back provisions, among others.

The Court focused on ERISA’s legislative history: Plans “established and maintained . . . by a church” have always been exempt from regulation under ERISA under the so-called “church plan” exemption. 29 U.S.C. §1002(33)(A). In addition, four years after ERISA’s enactment, Congress expanded the “church plan” exemption, stating:

A plan established and maintained for its employees . . . by a church . . . includes a plan maintained by an organization . . . the principal purpose . . . of which is the administration or funding of [such] plan . . . for the employees of a church . . . , if such organization is controlled by or associated with a church.

29 U.S.C. §1002(33)(C)(i). Federal agencies have long interpreted the amendment to mean that plans that are established and maintained by “principal purpose” organizations, such as internal benefits committees of church-affiliated hospitals, are except from ERISA. However, employees of three church-affiliated non-profit health care facilities filed separate lawsuits challenging this interpretation. The employees argued instead that ERISA’s plain language requires such plans to be establish by a church itself in order to fall within §1002(33)(C)(i). In each case, the district court agreed with the employees. The Third, Seventh, and Ninth Circuits all affirmed.

In an opinion written by Justice Elena Kagan, with Justice Neil Gorsuch not participating and Justice Sonia Sotomayor concurring, the Supreme Court reversed. The Court engaged in a protracted discussion of grammar and statutory construction, even noting that it would not “go down the rabbit hole of further expounding” on its hypothetical statute utilized in making its grammatical analysis. 2017 WL 2407476, at *6. Yet it ultimately concluded that Congress’s use of the phrase “includes” in its 1980 amendment indicates the intent to create an additional category receiving the same treatment as the preceding category, i.e. an additional exemption. The Court also found that the interpretation urged by the respondents would require it to ignore the words “established and” in §1002(33)(C)(i), thus running afoul of additional principles of statutory construction.

Following the Court’s decision, even where non-profit hospitals and other health care organizations are only loosely associated with a church, and the church has not been involved in establishing or maintaining the non-profit’s employee benefit plans, the plans offered to employees will not be subject to regulation under ERISA. For example, as the Court noted in a footnote, one of the petitioners was a large network of community hospitals with its only church connection amounting to the fact that the organization “maintains ties to the Catholic religious orders that initially sponsored some of its facilities.” 2017 WL 2407476, at *2. According to a 2016 report entitled “Growth of Catholic Hospitals and Health Systems,” 1 in 6 acute care hospitals are owned or affiliated with the Catholic Church. The Seventh-day Adventist Church health care system in the United States employs nearly 120,000 medical professionals in more than 85 hospitals.

Justice Sotomayor began her concurrence by reiterating ERISA’s protection of “ensuring ‘that if a worker has been promised a defined pension benefit upon retirement—and if he has fulfilled whatever conditions are required to obtain a vested benefit—he will actually receive it,’” 2017 WL 2407476, at *11, quoting Lockheed Corp. v. Spink, 517 U.S. 882, 887, 116 S.Ct. 1783, 135 L.Ed.2d 153 (1996). She expressed concern that affected non-profits include large organizations that very closely resemble secular businesses, with thousands of employees, for-profit subsidiaries, and billions of dollars in annual revenue. Despite such similarities, employees of church-affiliated non-profits will not be afforded ERISA’s protections and the body of unregulated “church plans” will expand.

The hospitals were represented by Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP, Greensfelder, Hemker & Gale, P.C., Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP, and Sills Cummis & Gross P.C.

The employees were represented by Keller Rohrback LLP, Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll PLLC, and James A. Feldman.

Cassie Ayeni, Springer Ayeni, A Professional Law Corp, http://www.benefitslaw.com, +1 (510) 926-6768 Ext: 1, [email protected]

Modal title

Contact PRWeb

  • 11AM ET Sunday – 8PM ET Friday
  • Contact Us

About PRWeb

  • About PRWeb
  • Partners
  • Partnership Programs
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Resources

Why PRWeb

  • Why PRWeb
  • How It Works
  • Who Uses It
  • Pricing

Accounts

  • Create a Free Account
  • Log in
  • Contact Us

Do not sell or share my personal information:

  • Submit via [email protected] 
  • Call Privacy toll-free: 877-297-8921

Contact Cision

Products

About

My Services
  • All News Releases
  • Online Member Center
  • ProfNet
Cision Distribution Helpline
888-776-0942
  • Legal
  • Site Map
  • RSS
  • Cookie Settings
Copyright © 2025 Cision US Inc.