Medicare Supplement Company Rankings

Share Article has ranked the top Medicare supplement companies for the first quarter of 2014.

News Image
Prices for Medicare supplement insurance vary wildly between companies within the same state, a leader in analyzing Medicare supplement plans, with help from CSG Actuarial, has ranked the top ten Medicare supplement companies for the beginning of 2014.

Premium price for Medicare supplement plans is one of the most important factors when making a decision on which insurance company to purchase your plan through. The plan benefits are regulated for most states and all plans provide the same benefits.

An Old Surety Plan F in Texas will have the exact same benefits as a Humana Plan F in Florida. Selecting your insurance company becomes the important decision when benefits are consistent. Current premium price and future price increase estimates should be analyzed when searching for a Medicare supplement plan.

Prices for Medicare supplement insurance vary wildly between companies within the same state. One insurance company is currently selling a Medigap Plan F (65 year-old female) for around $100 monthly premium in Texas and another company in Texas has priced their Plan F for over $210. The companies in this example have the same benefits and demonstrate the importance of comparing all Medicare supplement options.

Another example of volatility in Medigap pricing:

Georgia (30284) | Plan F (65 year-old female)

Lowest Monthly Premium = $124.59
Highest Monthly Premium = $250.00

You would save over $1,500 per year if you selected the lowest premium instead of the highest premium in Georgia. has provided company rankings based on average premium across all states below.

The Company Rankings

Plan F:

1)    Old Surety Life Insurance Company
2)    Stonebridge Life Insurance Company
3)    Cigna (American Retirement Life Insurance Company)
4)    Oxford Life Insurance Company
5)    New Era Life Insurance Company
6)    UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company
7)    Manhattan Life Insurance Company
8)    USAA Life Insurance Company
9)    Equitable Life & Casualty Insurance Company
10)    Aetna Life Insurance Company

Plan G:

1)    New Era Life Insurance Company
2)    Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company
3)    Stonebridge Life Insurance Company
4)    Cigna (American Retirement Life Insurance Company)
5)    Equitable Life & Casualty Insurance Company
6)    Aetna Life Insurance Company
7)    Government Personnel Mutual Life Insurance Company
8)    Central States Indemnity Company of Omaha
9)    Reserve National Insurance Company
10)    Banker’s Fidelity Life Insurance Company

All Plans:

1)    Old Surety Life Insurance Company
2)    Stonebridge Life Insurance Company
3)    New Era Life Insurance Company
4)    UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company
5)    Cigna (American Retirement Life Insurance Company)
6)    Central States Indemnity Company of Omaha
7)    Oxford Life Insurance Company
8)    Manhattan Life Insurance Company
9)    Aetna Life Insurance Company
10)    Equitable Life & Casualty Insurance Company


There are many choices to be made when signing up for Medicare. We want to make selecting an insurance company one of the easiest choices for you.

Our free report will provide the necessary insight for all available insurance options for your Medicare supplement product. This report will allow you to select the plan that fits your needs.

Review Medicare supplement options and generate insurance company comparison reports here:

Share article on social media or email:

View article via:

Pdf Print

Contact Author

Matt Neal
since: 01/2014
Follow >
Free Medicare Report
Like >
Follow us on
Visit website